Junior Hockey Video Evaluation System


Submit an Article to JuniorHockey.com »




Daily Dish: Are College Commitments Worthless? - Junior Hockey News


Tweet This
Published: Friday, 6 Jul 2012
By: Stephen Heisler  |  Web site: JuniorHockey.com

Student reporter Matt Slovin of the Michigan Daily has reported that Jacob Trouba, the #9 overall pick of the Winnipeg Jets, has an offer on the table worth $200,000 to play for the Ontario Hockey League's Kitcherner Rangers for 2012-2013.

Here's the text:

Monday night, a different OHL source informed the Daily that Kitchener has presented the Trouba family with a "huge offer" that remains on the table. The source added that he "believes it will happen."

In place of an education package, the source said Trouba could be compensated to about $200,000.

Kitchener head coach and general manager Steve Spott declined comment.  Link 

Trouba's family has since come out saying that the American prospect will be going to Ann Arbor to play for the Wolverines but the report has raised a lot of concerns. Are high end NCAA prospects getting lured to Canada with cash? Another Michigan prospect, Connor Carrick, suddenly flipped to join the Plymouth Whalers.

I have to believe that the entire system needs a serious overhaul. Verbal commitments are worthless. A new system should be put in place that the prospect signs as an adult at age 18. Players under 18 should not be included in the process. A written agreement should also go both ways and be in exchange for four or five years of education. The school should assume the risk of injury or making a bad decision.  If a player violates his (or her) end of the agreement than the school has the right to terminate it and seek full repayment of all benefits received.

There are way too many stories of coaches changing jobs and leaving a wake of lost scholarships behind because the new coach wants to bring in his own guys. 

I believe that if such a change would take place that we would see fewer news reports of college athletes misbehaving, or in the case of hockey, changing their minds.


Stephen Heisler resides in Puerto Penasco with his wife, Maria, and their two children, Sonia and Tomas. Friend him on Facebook 
http://www.facebook.com/#!/stephen.heisler for more information and pictures from Mexico. 




Discuss:

posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 1:36am
Cody Mesick says:
If a player commits to a college, then is drafted by an NHL team, and the NHL team wants that player to play in the CHL because of developmental reasons, why wouldn't the kid play in the CHL. And by the way, some kids play NCAA and turn 18 after they enroll in school and after the season starts, so that system is flawed. Both paths have their disadvantages and advantages, so I don't know why people get so heated about it. But apparently every junior hockey system in North America needs a complete overhaul according to this site.

posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 6:45am
Harry Urschel says:
The college system of one year scholarships absolutely needs overhaul. So does the system of coaches making wholesale changes both at mid-season and season's end.

The intent of attending college is to get an education not padding a coach's won-loss record.

If scholarships were 4 year contracts with penalties for early withdrawal, then maybe the high end kids would think more seriously about school and make more room for kids who want to stay in school.

posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 8:11am
Mike Beagy says:
What ever happened to capitalism?
$200,000 or $0 ???

99.9% of people would take the $200K.


posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 8:22am
Stephen Heisler says:
Cody,
I am not just talking about hockey here. Basketball tries to nab high school freshmen with verbal commitments. The practice is insane.

Take a look at the University of Kentucky's basketball team. Most of those kids are not there for an education and they are not staying for four years. In reality, they're are little more than the hired help.

Back to hockey, if a player signs on the dotted line to play college hockey, than that is it, he is at that school for the duration of his agreement with the school.

One of the biggest problems with our society is lack of consequences for breaking commitments.

When I talk about overhauling the player identification and selection process for junior hockey, I consider all the players that can't afford to get on the try-out train where they go from the USHL camps to the select camps to the NAHL camps to the showcase events... the costs are insane and it should not be that way.

There is no way that the system is effectively evaluating all the talent because not everybody can afford to take part in the money-grab. There are some exception players that fall through the cracks because they simply can't afford the costs to take part.

I am hearing stories about families that have had to take out second and third mortgages on their homes in order for their child(ren) to be a part of the developmental system. $10,000+ a year in some cases after paying the fee, travel, food, and equipment.

If we are not careful, hockey is going to price itself right out of contention at the international level.

posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 7:04pm
Devin Guertin says:
I definitely agree with you, hockey is getting very expensive and as of now i will never be able to play juniors at any level. which is very disappointing because its a dream but its unrealistic with the costs of everything

posted Jul. 6th, 2012 - 9:16pm
Randy Russon says:
Could it be that the alleged $200,000 payout is merely an education package worth that sum that only kicks in if the player does not play a single game of pro? Yes, it could be.

posted Jul. 10th, 2012 - 8:47am
Randy Russon says:
Kitchener Rangers sue student newspaper

Jets draft pick Trouba at centre of story

QMI Agency

First posted: Monday, July 09, 2012 09:25 PM EDT

First-round draft pick Jacob Trouba takes part in a drill at the Jets' development camp Monday. (SEBATIEN PERTH/QMI Agency)

The Kitchener Rangers of the OHL have taken legal action against a University of Michigan student newspaper and one of its reporters for publishing a story that alleged the team offered defenceman Jacob Trouba $200,000 to play for it.

A story that appeared in The Michigan Daily last week alleged that the Rangers tried to coax Trouba, a first-round draft pick of the Winnipeg Jets last month, out of a deal to play for the Michigan Wolverines.

The Rangers have now sued the newspaper and reporter Matt Slovin, according to the Waterloo Region Record.

"It's not a threat anymore," Rangers chief operating officer Steve Bienkowski told the Record Monday. "We served the newspaper and the writer there to either back it up or retract it."

The Rangers drafted Trouba two years ago but he declined to play, opting for the U.S. National Team Development Program instead. He has committed to Michigan but will lose his NCAA eligibility if he signs with the Jets.


posted Jul. 10th, 2012 - 9:10am
Stephen Heisler says:
We served the newspaper and the writer there to either back it up or retract it."

Really? This is going to be interesting to follow. Will the writer burn the source? I certainly hope not. I also don't eel that the paper is going to back down either. I wonder how far the University of Michigan is going go in defending the paper and writer.

Log in to post a comment

Log in with your Facebook account.
No registration required!:




Don't have a Facebook account?

Log in with your JuniorHockey.com account »

New visitors: Click here to create your JuniorHockey.com account »

( we'll bring you back here when you're finished! )







* Article disclaimer: This site may contain advice, opinions and statements from various authors and information providers. Views expressed in this article reflect the personal opinion of the author, Stephen Heisler, and not necessarily the views of JuniorHockey.com. JuniorHockey.com does not represent or endorse the accuracy or reliability of any advice, opinion, statement or other info provided in the article, or from any other member of this site.





About Us   |   Privacy   |   TOS   |   Copyright Policy   |   Advertise   |   Contact
Junior Hockey .com
562 Kingwood Dr, Ste 3, Kingwood, TX 77339
Sales Phone: (281) 973-2050
© 2013  JuniorHockey.com - All rights reserved.
Covering news for US Junior Hockey & Canadian Junior Hockey

View JuniorHockey.com Stats